Page 198 - English Grammar in Use
P. 198

Unit      Relative clauses 2:
         93       clauses with and without who/that/which




              A   Look at these example sentences from Unit 92:
                         The woman  who  lives next door to me is a doctor.  (or The woman that lives …)

                                 The woman  lives next  door to me      who (= the woman) is the subject

                         Where are the keys  that  were on the table?  (or … the keys which were …)
                                        The keys  were on the table     that (= the keys) is the subject
                  You must use who/that/which when it is the subject of the relative clause.  You cannot leave out
                  who/that/which in these examples.

              B   Sometimes who/that/which is the object of the verb.  For example:
                          The woman  who  I wanted to see was away on holiday.
                                                                    who (= the woman) is the object
                                          I wanted to see  the woman
                                                                    I is the subject
                         Did you find the keys  that  you lost?
                                                                    that (= the keys) is the object
                                                 you lost  the keys
                                                                    you is the subject
                  When who/that/which is the object, you can leave it out.  So you can say:
                         The woman I wanted to see was away.    or    The woman who I wanted to see …
                         Did you find the keys you lost?    or    … the keys that you lost?
                         The dress Lisa bought doesn’t fit her very well.    or    The dress that Lisa bought …
                         Is there anything I can do?    or    … anything that I can do?
                  Note that we say:
                      the keys you lost   (not the keys you lost them)
                      the dress Lisa bought   (not the dress Lisa bought it)

              C   Note the position of prepositions (to/in/for etc.) in relative clauses:

                         Tom is  talking to  a woman.  Do you know her?  (2 sentences)

                         Do you know the woman Tom is  talking to ? (or … the woman who/that Tom is talking to)
                         I  slept in  a bed.  It wasn’t comfortable.  (2 sentences)

                         The bed I  slept in  wasn’t comfortable.  (or  The bed that/which I slept in …)

                         Are these the books you were looking for?    or
                         Are these the books that/which you were …
                         The man I was sitting next to on the plane talked all the time.    or
                         The man who/that I was sitting next to …
                  Note that we say:
                      the books you were looking for   (not the books you were looking for them)
                      the man I was sitting next to   (not the man I was sitting next to him)

              D   We say:
                         Everything (that) they said was true.  (not Everything what they said)
                         I gave her all the money (that) I had. (not all the money what I had)
                  What = the thing(s) that:
                         What they said was true.  (= The things that they said)




        186           Relative clauses 1 ➜ Unit 92  Relative clauses 3–5 ➜ Units 94–96  whom ➜ Unit 94B
   193   194   195   196   197   198   199   200   201   202   203